Spray Booth Inspection for Compliance

Presented by John Owed

Most spray booth citations are avoidable. John Owed, Director of Sales at RTT Finishing Solutions, walks through real OSHA violations involving booth surfaces, airflow monitoring, fire suppression, clearances, spray areas and housekeeping. He explains what went wrong in each case and how distributors and end users can prevent the same mistakes.

Video Chapters

Thank you for joining us. Today we’re covering spray booth inspection for compliance. We’ll look at real examples of issues others have faced and learn how to avoid them. I’m John Owed, Director of Sales at RTT Finishing Solutions. Our facility is in Rockwall, Texas, just east of Dallas. We have an open-door policy and invite anyone to visit. RTT Finishing Solutions has three main business segments: Core catalog equipment: standard, pre-engineered spray booths, batch ovens, powder booths and larger booths, such as locomotive booths. We also modify and customize these products.Engineered projects: when customization gets more involved, this group handles highly specialized booths, such as one used to coat sections of large oil rigs. It also builds parts washers, from three-stage to seven-stage stainless steel systems, plus process ovens and components sold through our distributor and integrator partners. RP Filtration: we acquired the Research Products filtration line in 2017 and integrated manufacturing into our Rockwall facility. We’ve since focused on growing the line with added resources and programs. RTT is the only spray booth manufacturer that also manufactures filters. When you buy our booth and use our filters, we provide a five-year warranty on the booth and air makeup unit. Inspection introduction A quick disclaimer: we aren’t OSHA or NFPA experts. We have experience working through situations with distributors, customers and local authorities, and our goal is to clarify the terms and requirements. We always recommend getting an official opinion directly from an approval agency, and building a relationship with your local authority having jurisdiction (AHJ). In the end, the AHJ makes the judgment and interprets the code. We’ve all learned from our own mistakes. As Warren Buffett put it, it’s good to learn from your mistakes, but it’s better to learn from other people’s. That’s the premise of this presentation: what problems have others had, and how can we avoid them with our customers or in our own facilities? This presentation started with a search for OSHA and NFPA spray booth code violations. Most of the citations fall under OSHA 29 CFR 1910.107, which covers spray finishing with flammable and combustible materials. Note: the photos in this presentation are examples we’ve collected. They aren’t from the specific citations discussed. Booth surface standards Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $4,900. Issue: the interior surfaces of the spray booth were not smooth and continuous. Fines can sometimes be negotiated, waived or reduced if you resolve the issue promptly and follow up. Still, you’re looking at a potential $4,900 fine. Spray booth walls must be smooth, with no pockets where residue can collect and make cleaning difficult. The photo on the left is from a facility I visited, with permission. I could use it on almost every slide in this presentation. Someone built a wooden booth with a standard 20" x 20" opening to accept filter media. Apparently the small fan was pulling too much air, so they blocked off part of the opening. This booth would not meet the requirement and could receive a serious citation. The next photo is more typical: an existing booth with poor housekeeping. Overspray has built up so much on the walls that it’s now a potential violation. This booth also appears to have been modified after installation, with a crane slot added. RTT builds every booth to comply with all OSHA and NFPA requirements. When a booth is moved or modified, the person doing the work may not know the requirements, and that creates a potential violation. Here, the question is how close the fan motor is to the new opening. By code, a motor within 3 ft. of that opening must be rated for the location. That’s the value of learning from others’ mistakes: creating awareness with distributors and customers. In the first example, they could have bought an exhaust chamber for much less than a $4,900 fine. They spent a lot of time building something that wouldn’t pass code. Airflow monitoring Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $4,900. Issue: inadequate airflow and no working gauge. OSHA requires a spray booth to maintain at least 100 linear feet per minute (fpm) of airflow. With electrostatic application, it can be as low as 60 fpm. A visible gauge or audible alarm must also be installed to show that air velocity is maintained, or that the filters are loaded. In this case, the employer didn’t control airborne hazards effectively. Measured airflow was far below 100 fpm. Based on the numbers, the booth had about 80 sq. ft. of filter media, and the filters were clearly loaded and needed changing. The manometer wasn’t working because it had no oil in it. We see this often. Every RTT booth ships with a manometer, but sometimes it never gets hooked up. That’s a potential $4,900 violation over a part that costs under $100 and is simple to set up. Everyone should know how a manometer works, but many people don’t. To help, our YouTube channel has videos with Trey Peavy and Cayce Carr covering manometer installation and calibration. Trey also has a short video on the tools for measuring booth airflow, how to use them, and how to calculate airflow based on filter surface area. In this photo, the manometer is mounted inside the booth, right next to the filters. It’s accessible, but it’s a poor location. It’s covered in overspray, so even if it worked, you couldn’t read it. Clearly no one is checking it, because those filters are well past their usable life. A manometer is a very inexpensive way to avoid a $5,000 fine. Fire protection systems Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $7,000. Issue: no sprinkler system or fire suppression in the booth or behind the filters. All spray booths must have fire suppression, including under NFPA. This citation references sprinklers, but in my interpretation, the requirement is fire suppression: a way to stop a fire if one starts. This photo shows a dry chemical system with nozzles in the booth and in the exhaust stack. In this case, one older booth had sprinklers in the spray enclosure but not in the exhaust stack. Another booth had no fire suppression at all. We often assume people know this, but any booth spraying hazardous materials can encounter an ignition source, such as a spark. Fire suppression is required. Clearance requirements Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $4,900. Issue: housekeeping, and not maintaining at least 3 ft. of clear space on all sides of the booth, free from storage and combustible construction. In this photo, the booth is closer than 3 ft. to the wall, and the two booths are closer than 3 ft. to each other. If inspected, this facility would likely be cited and need significant changes. We often get asked how close a booth can be to a wall. The recommendation is a minimum of 3 ft. of clearance on the back and all sides. The requirement is really 3 ft. or zero: you can put a booth directly against a wall if the wall is fire-rated. Here, the walls are block and would have a fire rating, but the gap is large enough for material to accumulate behind the booth. This is easy to avoid during planning. On larger projects, we provide booth dimensions and approval drawings. If the customer provides site information, we can place the booth in the facility layout, so everyone knows where it’s going and that it complies as we interpret the code. Spray area safety Citation: serious violation under 1910.107(c)(2), minimum separation, potential fine of $7,000. This citation listed five issues and relates to a spray area rather than a spray booth, which has different requirements. One issue was an open-flame salamander heater within 20 ft. of the designated spray area. We see combinations like this often: an electric drill that produces sparks sitting in a bucket of solvent-borne paint, just outside the booth. That’s a serious safety hazard. We’ve also all seen grinding or welding near booths or spray areas where product is sitting out or dry overspray has built up. Welding near loaded filters never ends well. Most of these issues come down to housekeeping and good practices. Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $5,500. Issue: combustible residue and explosive vapors in the area, with non-rated equipment. We often see auxiliary halogen or LED lighting, radios and other devices in and around spray areas. Hazardous location rules NFPA has specific requirements for spray areas. Spray areas are typically used for large parts, such as a 100 ft. steel column or a structure that won’t fit in a conventional booth. Requirements include: Construction from non-combustible or limited-combustible materials Smooth interior surfaces, free of areas where residue can accumulate Construction with a 2-hour fire-resistance rating Electrical wiring and equipment that is either approved for the location or beyond 20 ft. away Around a spray area, the surrounding space becomes Class I, Division 2. That zone extends 10 ft. above and 20 ft. horizontally from the spray area. Standard lighting within 10 ft. above must be explosion-proof. Above that, standard lighting is fine. Standard electrical devices must be more than 20 ft. away. The zone accounts for where overspray can billow and settle. This photo is a good example of what not to do. The spray area has a small exhaust plenum vented outside, which is good. But the motor is most likely not explosion-proof and isn’t rated for the location. The hanging light is within the 10 ft. vertical zone. There’s a compressor within 20 ft., the walls aren’t smooth, and the glass window doesn’t have a 2-hour fire rating. These are the things to watch for when you’re advising customers on setting up safe spray environments. Sprinkler head protection Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $4,900. Issue: sprinklers were installed in the booth but not protected from overspray. During my research, I found a Minnesota State Fire Marshal bulletin on NFPA 13 and proper sprinkler head protection. Approved methods are a thin paper bag, such as a lunch bag, or a cellophane bag 0.003 in. thick or less. It must be cellophane, not plastic. Standard sandwich bags are plastic. Cellophane burns away quickly, so it doesn’t delay the water release. Many of these details come down to the AHJ. I worked in a lab for many years, and one year the fire marshal would say use paper bags, and the next year say use plastic. Interpretations vary, so seek guidance from your AHJ. But sprinkler heads must be protected so overspray doesn’t build up and delay their release at the designated temperature. Predetermined spray area Citation: serious violation, potential fine of $5,500. Issue: spraying was conducted outside the predetermined spray area. We see this often: a company has a spray booth but sprays outside it. Typically it’s someone working a foot or two beyond the booth width on a longer part. This photo is a more extreme example from a facility I visited. They complained about paint odors throughout the shop. They had a 20 ft. exhaust plenum but were spraying parts across a 140 ft. area. One solution is to turn the parts perpendicular and add curtains to direct airflow. The other is to add about 130 ft. of exhaust plenum, plus curtains. And any time you exhaust that much air, you also have to replace it. When the weather is nice, they also leave the doors open. The booth pulls air from the doorway instead of pulling vapors from the far end of the parts. This facility had no manometer connected either. I held a sheet of paper up to the filters, and it dropped to the floor. The filters were so loaded that the booth wasn’t exhausting. There’s a lot of education to be done. It’s an opportunity to help customers create a safer spray environment and to sell them filters. These basics are easy to fix and far less expensive than a fine and the added oversight that follows. A little better housekeeping prevents a lot of headaches. Housekeeping and fire Citation: serious violation, potential fine of [$400 as stated, confirm]. Issue: the booth floor was not kept free of combustible residue. We see this often: filters that should have been changed a month ago, overspray on the walls, paint cans and a trash hopper full of debris. Any ignition source would spread rapidly in an environment like this. Why is housekeeping so important? This is the worst-case scenario. This customer’s thermal event was caused by welding. Because the booth was dirty, combustible residue covered the floor and walls, and loaded filters were left in place, one stray spark made the booth a total loss. There was substantial damage to the building. The booth’s sprinklers put the fire out quickly and contained it, but there was water and smoke damage throughout the facility. Fortunately, it happened during a slow period, so they could rebuild without major impact. Basic housekeeping, such as cleaning up, changing filters and monitoring airflow, helps prevent this. Summary and compliance When we design a spray booth, it’s built to comply with all OSHA and NFPA standards. We can coach distributors and customers on where to locate the booth in their facility. But things change. The booth location may move at the last minute, or the booth may be modified. In the crane slot example, did whoever cut that slot consider that the fan motor might now be too close to the opening, where overspray could billow out? Fires aren’t easy to start, and the conditions have to be right, but they still happen too often. The purpose of this presentation is to learn from others’ mistakes and help you become an advocate for your customers by flagging potential issues and coaching them through them. As I said at the start, I’m not an expert. Others at RTT have much more experience, and we can help. But the final say comes down to the AHJ. That could be the local fire marshal or another inspector, depending on the area, and it depends on how they interpret the code. When you get involved in a project, engage the AHJ up front to understand how they want things done. If you ask for forgiveness instead, it can be much harder to get their help and coaching. Q&A An end user wants to replace the drawers in a spray-to-waste cartridge collector with a cardboard box for powder collection. Is that an issue under NFPA or OSHA? I’ll need to research that and follow up with an official answer. As a best practice, I wouldn’t recommend using paper, cardboard or wood inside a spray booth unless it’s rated non-flammable. Where is the best place to mount the manometer? Outside the spray booth, typically on the side of the exhaust chamber. The manometer has two ports. One connects inside the exhaust chamber. The other connects to the open environment for an open-face booth, or inside the booth for an enclosed booth. Mount it where it’s easy to see and won’t get covered in overspray. What’s the difference between Class I, Division 2 and Class II, Division 2? Class I, Division 1 is typically the area inside the spray booth, where vapors exist under normal operation. Class I, Division 2 is the adjacent area, where vapors may exist but aren’t normally present. That’s the difference between Division 1 and Division 2. Class I relates to liquid, and Class II relates to powder. If sprinklers are required in spray booths, what should a customer do if the building has no sprinklers? This happens often. The best step is to talk to the AHJ. The dry chemical system I showed earlier was from Kidde, which makes dry chemical fire suppression systems. You’d most likely be directed to that type of system, which typically includes a canister and a detection system that triggers its release. But check with your AHJ first. Why are booth airflow requirements lower for electrostatic applications? Electrostatic application has higher transfer efficiency. More paint goes on the part, so there’s less overspray and fewer vapors in the air to contain and capture. It matters most with soft spray patterns, such as rotary atomizers, that rely more on the electrostatic process. Lower booth velocity keeps the airflow from pulling the paint away from the part. Closing Our who-to-call list shows each regional sales manager’s territory and contact information. It’s included in the presentation handout and on our website. Webinar presentations are available on our website, and recordings are on our YouTube channel. The channel also has helpful how-to videos, such as manometer setup and airflow measurement, which are especially useful for training new hires. For more information, contact us. Thank you for attending.

Additional Resources

Not Sure Which System You Need?

Get a system built around your application, with the right airflow, filtration, and fit for your facility.

Request A Quote

With over 75 years of combined experience engineering complex, multi-component finishing solutions, our team has the expertise to design and build equipment for projects of any scale — tailored precisely to your specifications.

 

Share a few details below and we’ll have a proposal back to you within 24 hours.